Having said that, the primary reason they are so popular is simply because it reduces the amount of ammunition and magazines you need to carry or store, since if you're carrying a PCC you're likely carrying a handgun in the matching magazine and round, otherwise they quickly lose their benefit. I would generally recommend to avoid PCC's as a whole as they do not offer a singular upside over any other weapon in every possible scenario. Get it as a pistol.Īny recommendations for a dependable and accurate option? With self defense ammunition, you're not going to worry nearly as much about overpenetration as you would with a 5.56, and that's a major selling point for the Scorpion, but again, i wouldn't want it in carbine configuration. Comparatively a Carbine Scorpion put up against a Carbine AR15, is all around less useful than the AR15 due to the cartridge limitations at range, though the upside of anything 9mm vs. If the fear is a close up defensive situation, Shotgun>Pistol in my eyes in terms of useful DW's. This is mainly why they are popular in civilian forms, they look cool and are pretty fun at the range shooting at much shorter distances where the effectiveness of the round really doesn't get challenged. I realize range is pretty bad, but it seems like a fun range gun and would be okay for close up defense situations? Lighter weight, more maneuverable, and you're firing the same round either way. A Sig P320 of any number variants would be in my mind, more ideal in almost every possible scenario or setting. The real version of that gun is meant to be a Pistol/SBR variant with automatic fire, and if you're going to be stuck with the length requirements of a carbine, you might as well be using most defense shotguns or even a bullpup configuration like a Tavor X95 in 300blk, or a PS90 in 5.7.ĭepending on the handgun, I'd indefinitely take that over a Carbine Scorpion. I already have a 12 gauge home defense gun and two AR15s.ĭepending on the 12 gauge and the AR's, I'd probably stick with those as my home defense options over a neutered Carbine Scorpion. Small, compact, relatively concealable in their intended SBR/Pistol forms, doubly so in their automatic versions with significant fire rate and stopping power in CQB. There's a reason firearms like the CZ and endless quantities of the MP variants exist, they do a job very well. I think you meant to ask if its an okay choice for a PDW, and it is an absolutely STELLAR PDW my friend. No, 9mm is god awful as a defensive long gun, but I also don't believe that's what you mean. Those guys will eat ass and spit brass all day long without issue!Īre they an okay choice for a defensive long gun? While I'm personally not a fan of PCC's, I am quite a big fan of the CZ scorpion and its reliability. In general, are these fairly reliable firearms? I am considering adding a 9mm carbine such as a CZ Scorpion or Sig MPX to my collection. Salon: Gun control’s racist reality: The liberal argument against giving police more power NY Magazine: There Is No ‘Epidemic of Mass School Shootings’ The New York Times: The Assault Weapons Myth 538 on Americans misunderstanding gun violence and policy solutions The Rifle on the Wall: A Left Argument for Gun Rights National African-American Gun Association This does not mean "classical liberal" or right-leaning libertarians. Those who would identify as Democrats, Progressives, Socialists, &c. "Liberal" here is "left-of-center", in US political terms. This is a place for liberal gun-owners who want to discuss gun ownership absent the "noise" of most right-leaning pro-gun forums. Gun ownership through a pro-gun liberal lens.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |